Dr. James Kugel responds to Dr. Moshe Bernstein's opinion piece about his speech at YU (link to Dr. Bernstein's, link to Dr. Kugel's). In my opinion, Dr. Kugel's letter is disingenuous because:
- He implies that his views are traditional without directly responding to Dr. Bernstein's assertions that he denies Torah from Sinai and is not consistent with even a minority view within the Jewish tradition.
- He suggests that Dr. Bernstein believes in hiding from modern scholarship when Dr. Bernstein explicitly advocates studying it, including Dr. Kugel's contributions, but in the appropriate venues and in ways that do not glamorize non-traditional views.